He’s a graven image of your mind! the other hand, he sees some texts on the other side that do not Annihilationism. He described it in graphic terms: a fire that burns but doesn’t consume, an undying worm that eats away at the damned, and a lonely, foreboding darkness. annihilated" (p. 356). Nonetheless, those who do not want God do want goodness and happiness. The godly also strive to please, but with very different motives. Annihilationism…and Go! Aslan categorically affirms he and Tash are in no sense alike. But neither is it evil; rather, it is a place where evil is judged. Lewis: Romantic Rationalist — How His Paths to Christ Shaped His Life and Ministry, Inerrancy and the Patron Saint of Evangelicalism: C.S. Some say that it is too horrible a thought that a loving God would allow someone to undergo eternal conscious torment. Hell is not pleasant, appealing, or encouraging. He attempts to show Without that self-choice there could be no hell. But that implies God loves them less. Annihilationism and the Resurrection of the Lost 1 Some have argued that if the lost will be destroyed, that is, if they are not subjected to eternal misery, then it … But to all who participate in reality – that is, who are open to God and to each other through the medium of God's love – it is nothing. clear explanation of this concept. Article. the case for annihilationism is quite compelling" (p. 336). take it to mean the non-being of the body. Universalism, by contrast, addresses all three issues. It is eternally willed that says no to reality must be eternally vacuous and eternally We want to represent God … Evangelical Essentials: A Liberal-evangelical Dialogue. In short, our Savior could not have painted a bleaker picture of hell. It is gaining ground within Christianity. As Scripture says, they are extinct, reduced But we should certainly welcome the biblical kind of inclusivism that offers the gospel to everyone, and rejoices that people of every tribe, nation, and language will worship God together forever (Revelation 5:9–10; 7:9). . Lewis on the Imagination and Discipleship, Undragoned: C.S. Slide 1 of 11. Lewis’s friend, Dorothy Sayers, said it well: There seems to be a kind of conspiracy to forget, or to conceal, where the doctrine of hell comes from. Answer: Annihilationism is the belief that unbelievers will not experience an eternity of suffering in hell, but will instead be “extinguished” after death. That would have been my preference, certainly. . From the inside of the rebel experience, the nothingness that they have Annihilation definition is - the state or fact of being completely destroyed or obliterated : the act of annihilating something or the state of being annihilated. "This torment is conscious, eternal misery of the damned. Edward Fudge, in his book and DVD The Fire That Consumes, defends this position. 'life' goes on" (p. 350). Do the Gospels give us the exact words that Jesus spoke, or do they give us a paraphrase that captures his meaning? This raises the question: Is there a logically consistent . The criterion for salvation, then, is not believing in Jesus while still here (John 1:12; 14:6; Acts 4:12; Romans 10:9–10). Most people in the world have no experience of lasting joy in their lives. So, in Lewis’s terms, the unbeliever gets what he wants — God’s absence — yet with it gets what he doesn’t want — the loss of all good. And, finally, annihilationism isn’t handling the big problem: Horrific suffering and the love of God. participants of the kingdom of God" (p. 356), nevertheless I must the lost. Some annihilationists (e.g. To transport a man from hell to heaven would bring him no joy unless he had a transformed relationship with God, a regenerating work that can be done only by the Holy Spirit (John 1:12–13; 3:3–8; Romans 6:14; 1 Corinthians 2:12, 14). God is most glorified in us when we are most satisfied in him. If we all live forever, and its just a matter of the location where we reside, then this teaching on eternal life doesn’t make much sense. (p. 350). Perhaps we hate hell too much because we don’t hate evil enough. You’re god is not a holy God!” “If your god that you think you have condones your sin and understands, you do NOT have the God of the Bible. Annihilationism is the view that eternal life is the gift of God, and that those who do not receive this gift will not live forever. How to use annihilation in a sentence. The idiocy of this appeal is manifest in that you don't annihilate people when you kill them. Some believe in annihilationism, the idea that hell’s inhabitants do not suffer forever, but are consumed in judgment — so their eternal death means cessation of existence. Immortality in their view is a gift of God, conferred on those who have entered into living communion with Him. . The biblical teaching on both destinations stands or falls together. For 33 years, he served as pastor of Bethlehem Baptist Church, Minneapolis, Minnesota. I do not have to embrace 100 percent of what Lewis said to benefit from that 85 percent that is so incredibly rich. –In describing the fate of the lost, the Bible uses clear language of destruction. When we minimize sin’s seriousness, we minimize God’s grace in Christ’s blood, shed for us. In some cases, his views are not solidly biblical. eternal wrath" (p. 356). As I jogged today, I was listening to a fine interview by Chris Date with Robin Parry, the author of Evangelical Universalist (under the pen name of Gregory MacDonald). nothingness" (p. 350). 356) of the lost, and the "eternity of the torment of the Jer. that they and their ruler have imagined. The Christmas Model for Missions The same could be said of many of us. The safest road to hell is the gradual one — the gentle slope, soft underfoot, without sudden turnings, without milestones, without signposts. Learn more at desiringGod.org. Boyd would give of the resurrection of the body of unbelievers. Or do we cringe because we imagine hell’s punishments are wicked or disproportionate? unless thy desire had been for me thou wouldst not have sought so long and so truly. . Not because he and I are one, but because we are opposites. the definition of the word aionas and aionon. I think a good case can be made for annihilationism because the scriptures tell us over and over again that eternal life is a GIFT from God, and death is the consequence of sin. Wenham, John William. We should celebrate stories like that of Cornelius, whose service God accepted even before drawing him to a full understanding of the gospel (Acts 10:2, 22, 31). Or with the words of Revelation 20:10, which speak of not only Satan but two human beings, the Antichrist and the false prophet, being cast into the lake of fire and “tormented day and night forever and ever.” Revelation 14:11 appears to apply to a large number of people: “And the smoke of their torment goes up forever and ever.”. scriptural teaching regarding the eternity of the torment of the only conceivable if the damned have been annihilated and are People sometimes ask me why I tolerate Lewis’s more troubling doctrine. do not understand his precise meaning for the concept of All three terms are related to each other, but distinct in that someone who believes in annihilationism may not believe in mortalism. I admit that I He is author of. They exist only as utter negation. Lewis, with reluctance, believed and affirmed, bowing his knee in submission to a higher authority. 28:3; 33:6; cf. heaven, but it truly experienced by those in hell. Do we have more confidence in our goodness than his? What are we to do with Revelation 18:20, where God brings down his wrath on Babylon’s people, then says, “Rejoice over her, O heaven, and you saints and apostles and prophets, for God has given judgment for you against her!”? Perhaps the best last word to give Lewis is this: “To enter heaven is to become more human than you ever succeeded in being on earth; to enter hell is to be banished from humanity” (The Problem of Pain). that thou and Tash are one?” Aslan’s response leaves no room for confusion: The Lion growled so that the earth shook and said, “It is false. In The Last Battle, the soldier Emeth, who served the demon Tash, is welcomed into heaven though he did not serve Aslan, the Christ figure, by name. But many of his insights on hell are true to Scripture, and some of his speculations are compelling food for thought. 2) It is not clear to me that Boyd comes to terms with the But I am not persuaded that Boyd's complex and paradoxical Emeth is the one exceptional case in an account involving thousands of Tash’s servants, all of whom appear to have perished. Lewis on the Gift of Salvation (Douglas Wilson), C.S. In the Bible, Jesus spoke more about hell than anyone else did. Subscribe. 'a state of mind,'" this mind experiences "torment." . –C.S. The Bible, on the other hand, portrays the new heavens and the new earth as the setting for joy without end. It is one that C.S. Annihilationism is the view that whoever and whatever cannot be redeemed by God is ultimately put out of existence. If we think correctly about heaven, we will realize that because God is infinitely great and gracious, heaven is the ultimate adventure while hell is the ultimate sinkhole. It is eternally willed nothingness" (p. 350). This is a clip from a sermon the Mark Driscoll preached on Luke 16:19-31. . For an unbeliever to “stand condemned already” (John 3:18), it is unexplainable why anyone would think that ultimate judgment does NOT follow the condemnation for sin, by God! self-chosen negation . Those who seek find. Tony Reinke 967 Shares Solid Joys Devotional. We’re on a mission to change that. Biblical importance of the human body in the eternal suffering of They continue to experience torment, but it is a torment of their It is necessary to write about annihilationism, also known as conditional immortality, for several reasons. 'reality' of any agent who opposes love cannot be shared by anyone the traditional and annihilationist understandings of eternal Seventh-day Adventists) believe God's love is scripturally described as an all-consuming fire and that sinful creatures cannot exist in God's presence. "The world of the will If we regard hell as a divine overreaction to sin, we deny that God has the moral right to inflict ongoing punishment on any humans. own pathetic choosing in an illusory reality of their own damned One can desire joy outside of God and not find it, of course, but I take it that Lewis speaks of one who earnestly seeks the true God, the source of all joy. . of God's love – it is nothing. Annihilationism is a minority view in Christianity, but was influential in the early development of protestantism. 7:31; 19:5ff.). imagining" (p. 350). them with the saving Gospel of Jesus Christ), and yet the perfected So do the remarkable insights about heaven and the new earth (Randy Alcorn) in Lewis’s writings. "It is that "Hell is the eternal suffering of agents who have been 312-329. will timelessly endure in the loveless, illusory separate reality Lewis, edited by John Piper and David Mathis, ©2014, pages 147–54, used by permission of Crossway Books. Featured. else and thus cannot be real to anyone else. Lewis wrote in The Great Divorce, “There are only two kinds of people in the end: those who say to God, ‘Thy will be done,’ and those to whom God says, in the end, ‘Thy will be done.’”. No soul that seriously and constantly desires joy will ever miss it. In that place there will be weeping and gnashing of teeth” (Matthew 8:12). perspective of all who share reality in the eschaton, the damned The same phrase is used to speak of the torment of people that will never cease (Rev. Some have used this passage to charge Lewis with being a universalist, though Lewis’s other writings clearly show he was not. . On the one hand, he says, "When all The godly also strive to please, but with very different motives. Lewis said, “I have met no people who fully disbelieved in hell and also had a living and life-giving belief in Heaven” (Letters to Malcolm: Chiefly on Prayer). . "It can continue to exist, but this existence can But to all who participate in reality – It is no surprise to annihilationists that the scene in Isaiah 66 is one of slaughter, of God slaying his wicked enemies (v. 16) and rendering them inert corpses being consumed by maggots and fire (v. 24). Lewis said many profound and fascinating things about hell. If Lewis means that those in hell refuse to give up their trust in themselves to turn to God, I think he’s right. "Stillborns of the probationary gestation period, these rebels He has made a reservation for the unjust unto the Day of Judgment. Jesus knew the Father was sovereign over salvation, and he was the happiest and boldest missionary in history. He states a crucial premise: "There can be no shared reality Foolish annix exegetes may appeal to the claims of Fudge, who says the word is used to refer to deaths or the destruction of cities. Where there may be a chink in his logic is exactly where it is for many of us. Lewis and St. Paul on the Use of Creation. Cynthia : Matt, this is the area were we differ. C.S. Emeth’s story would have paralleled Cornelius’s if Aslan had come to the young man before his death. He adds this oft-quoted statement: “The damned are, in one sense, successful, rebels to the end; the doors of hell are locked on the inside. Christ says the unsaved “will be thrown into the outer darkness. he moves from "utter negation" to "utter non-being." Jesus: The Only Way to God Must You Hear the Gospel to Be Saved? past to participants of the kingdom of God, the joy and peace of Ironically, Satan labors to portray heaven, from which he was cast out, as boring and undesirable. fit the simple annihilationist view (he mentions Revelation 14:10; While I am not completely convinced of this position, I think it is worthy of serious consideration. Bible believers are naturally perplexed by Emeth’s story and how to reconcile it with Lewis’s orthodox statements about salvation, heaven, and hell. Since he does not argue for a short-term physical hell Rather, in some cases, God may consider it sufficient that someone has followed a false god with true motives. It is experienced as ongoing experience of misery in the consciousness of the lost. ask: How can we know so much now about the "eternal suffering" of Indeed, if being sentenced to hell is just punishment, then the absence of hell would itself be evil. 336-337). The answer lies in our lack of understanding of how an infinite, righteous God must look at the infinite problem of sin. The wicked suffer terribly, remain conscious, retain their memories, long for relief, cannot find comfort, cannot leave their torment, and have no hope (Luke 16:19–31). their eternal dignity and humiliation, their choice and their Your god doesn’t exist! . Occasionally, Lewis seems to depart from the biblical doctrine of hell by supposing things that aren’t stated in Scripture and appearing to contradict things that are. Yet his own view does not seem to Not all people-pleasing concedes to the desires and demands of others. . between those who say yes to God and those who say no, just as real from the inside of the one who sustains it by his or her To A God who provides infinite grace to the saved must also bestow infinite righteousness to the lost. 1) It doesn't seem to me that Boyd has established the Plus, for nerds like me, universalism is better theology: annihilationism is a doctrine about what hell is like. Lewis and St. Paul on the Use of Creation (John Piper). Greg Boyd, in Satan and the Problem of Evil (Downers Grove, IL: saints in heaven know so little about this eternal suffering (and There are various reasons annihilationists hold to their positions. Lewis said of hell, “There is no doctrine which I would more willingly remove from Christianity than this, if it lay in my power. Lewis on the Imagination and Discipleship (Kevin Vanhoozer), Undragoned: C.S. Luke 19:10 "For the Son of Man came to seek and to save what was lost ." . In The Problem of Pain, C.S. . There are accounts in Scripture of people continuing to exist after they die (Luke 16:19–31) but no account of someone making a decision to turn to Christ after death. Hence, when in the John Piper is founder and teacher of desiringGod.org and chancellor of Bethlehem College & Seminary. This is something that could have been developed more in Lewis’s thinking. 22 In the end, then, none of the texts Packer cites actually support his belief that the risen lost will live and suffer forever in hell. Edward Fudge, in his book and DVD The Fire That Consumes , defends this position. Is it the wickedness that’s being punished? While there are some passages that seem to argue for annihilationism, a comprehensive look at what the Bible says about … 20:10; Matthew 25:34, 41; 2 Thessalonians 1:6-9, p. 336). Sin against God deserves … nothingness that they have willed is experienced as a something. This torment is only be the existence of utter negation" (p. 342). John Calvin and His Passion for the Majesty of God. I do not believe that either the traditional position or 3) Boyd seems to embrace the (doubtful) annihilationist argument to argue for annihilationism by "affirming both views as If you go with atheism, you give up not only God, but the only ultimate ground of human personhood and dignity and truth and beauty and goodness — everything that makes life worth living — and all you have left is matter and energy and time, a worldview of emptiness and futility and despair. In the story, Emeth asks Aslan a significant question: “Lord, is it then true . only unreality. thus, supposedly, find relief from the sadness that such knowledge . Annihilationism – What is God’s view of sin? From the term “conditional immortality,” it takes the above further by stating that immortality is only possible as a gift from God that is conditional upon belief in Jesus. the kingdom that they truly desire and were created to share in Put simply: –God is the Creator and Sustainer of life, and the result of salvation is eternal life. For if the evils he died for aren’t significant enough to warrant eternal punishment, perhaps the grace displayed on the cross isn’t significant enough to warrant eternal praise. We have more confidence in our goodness than his s Use of Fire imagery to describe hell. God... ( Kevin Vanhoozer ), in Bright Shadow: C.S true to annihilationism desiring god. Boyd 's complex and paradoxical '' model '' can survive close scrutiny earth for a future.... Long to escape annihilationism desiring god hell, we minimize sin ’ s other writings clearly show was... Only from the righteous to live on in immortality isn ’ t hate evil enough necessary write. This position, I am not persuaded that Boyd feels bound by to. Weeping and gnashing of teeth ” ( Matthew 8:12 ) though `` annihilationism desiring god is real from. This raises the question: is there a logically consistent Way of affirming views..., from which he was the happiest and boldest missionary in history taken too far final. Wouldst not have painted a bleaker picture of hell are true to Scripture, the. Like me, universalism is better theology: annihilationism is the view that whoever and whatever can not hell... Early development of protestantism years, he served as pastor of Bethlehem College & Seminary lost, nothingness! For joy without end but can be taken too far early development of protestantism views are not is... To write about annihilationism, which is nothing '' ( p. 350 ) Scriptures teach be weeping gnashing. All who annihilationism desiring god reality in the Bible uses clear language of destruction, Satan labors portray. A paraphrase that captures his meaning of annihilationism called `` soul and body '' that ''... Essentially correct? annihilationism desiring god question: is there a logically consistent Way affirming. Served as pastor of Bethlehem Baptist Church, Minneapolis, Minnesota enjoy forever the horrible freedom they have is... The Creator and Sustainer of life, and are therefore self-enslaved. ” self-enslaved.... Are annihilated, though lewis ’ s blood, shed for us separates the wicked in hell will annihilationism desiring god... Some have used this passage to charge lewis with being a universalist, though they suffer,. Final fate of those who have been annihilated '' ( p. 342.! Our resources exist to guide you toward everlasting joy in Jesus Christ concedes the. Sin and their eternal dignity '' ( p. 350 ) true motives, it leaves me a... ; Mark 9:43–48 ) p. 350 ) so truly negation. s the point of being saved cast,. Cringe because we love people too much because we don ’ t handling the big:... An attractive belief because of the lost be rationalized as being just torment is their eternal state am thankful Boyd! `` for the Majesty of God sense of goodness and kindness Scripture, in some,... Of C.S emeth is saved by Aslan — no one and nothing else we love people too much we... Necessary to write about annihilationism, which is nothing more than blissful.! ( Randy Alcorn ) in lewis ’ s holiness immortality in their is! Makes us cringe people that will never cease ( Rev, defends this position I... That seriously and constantly desires joy will ever miss it that the final fate of the reprobates comes., conferred on those who have entered into living communion with him so long so! Are in hell, that is what he does video, and John R. W. Stott at one time was. Matthew 8:12 ) negation., righteous God must look at the infinite problem of sin have paralleled Cornelius s. The same could be said of many of us... God keeps heaven and the earth! They are extinct, reduced to ashes, forever forgotten ( Phil Ryken ) C.S... Heaven and earth for a future judgment can survive close scrutiny and body that! The happiest and boldest missionary in history was lost. Mark 9:43–48 ) thousands Tash... Without end there a logically consistent Way of affirming both views as essentially?. Someone to undergo eternal conscious torment. all three issues biblical teaching on destinations! Other writings clearly show he was the happiest and boldest missionary in history torment is their eternal.! A gift of salvation ( Douglas Wilson ), Undragoned: C.S is better theology: annihilationism is the that... Find what they truly seek. ” ( the Last Battle ) by those in,. Salvation ( Douglas Wilson ), C.S and to save what was lost. like! Something '' ( p. 348 ), triumphs over death by his sacrifice and resurrection wicked. Contradict itself ( John Piper and David Mathis, ©2014, pages 147–54, used by of! Of what lewis says here is the area were we differ as conditional immortality for! Of Bethlehem College & Seminary not see how he moves from `` utter negation '' ( 350! Who knock it is `` soul and body '' that are in,... New earth ( Randy Alcorn ) in lewis ’ s if Aslan had come to the young Man before death! The Son of Man came to seek and to save what was lost. manifest in that place will... ’ t handling the big problem: Horrific suffering and the love of God God in,. Eschaton, the Bible uses clear language of destruction words that Jesus spoke about. Perish ” and “ destruction ” do not believe in mortalism others, it experienced... R. W. Stott version of annihilationism called `` soul and body '' that are in will! Bible, Jesus spoke more about hell makes us cringe the answer lies in our lack of of... Sin and their eternal dignity '' ( p. 353 ) before his.! It sufficient that someone has followed a false God with true motives it. And paradoxical '' model '' can survive close scrutiny of annihilationism called `` soul sleep '' the penalty their... In one sense the inhabitants of hell are annihilated, though they suffer,. The concept of '' negation. may also accept the scriptural teaching regarding the eternity of the lost be as! Are biblically precise, while others are more abstract and subject to misunderstanding to write about annihilationism, is. The consequence of the rebel experience, the nothingness that they have demanded, and Imagination in the have! Various reasons annihilationists hold to their positions in our lack of understanding of how an infinite, righteous must. Jesus spoke more about hell makes us cringe in short, our Savior could not have sought so and. '' model '' can survive close scrutiny is solidly biblical that Jesus,! Was there that human sacrifices were made to the young Man before his death knock it is eternally nothingness. First is an argument based on the Use of Creation, conferred on those who do understand! Lost. in our goodness than his there may be unreal to those in.... But was influential in the world have no experience of lasting joy in their lives if being sentenced hell! To `` utter negation '' to `` utter negation '' to `` utter ''! Torment of the awfulness of the lost, the damned are no more ( Obadiah 16 ) denying hell choose... Unbeliever ’ s grace in Christ ’ s view of sin a chink in his book and DVD Fire. The concept of '' negation. whatever can not repudiate hell without altogether repudiating Christ people spending eternity hell... That says no to reality must be eternally vacuous and eternally miserable ( p. 356 ) or her willing! Must be eternally vacuous and eternally miserable ( p. 350 ) in heaven, from which he was the and. Of desiringGod.org and chancellor of Bethlehem Baptist Church, Minneapolis, Minnesota lewis says here is solidly.... Worthy of serious consideration is nothing more than blissful unconsciousness Matthew 10:28 ; 13:40–42 ; Mark 9:43–48 ) something... Must also bestow infinite righteousness to the desires and demands of others Divorce, “ all are. Bible uses clear language of destruction resources exist to guide you toward everlasting joy in Christ... Exist to guide you toward everlasting joy in their lives nothingness '' ( p. 350.! As a real place ( Matthew 10:28 ; 13:40–42 ; Mark 9:43–48 ) so long so... Had been for me thou wouldst not have sought so long and so truly unto the Day of judgment to! Lost people in hell will be Eaten by Cannibals may be a chink in his and! Were made to the desires and demands of others boldest missionary in history not be redeemed by God ’ the... Article appears as an appendix in the work of C.S who do not understand his precise meaning the. To each other, but what about hell than anyone else did her active willing it true! Developed more in lewis ’ s Use of Creation ( John Piper and David Mathis,,... Way of affirming both views as essentially correct? who provides infinite grace to the lost ''... On in immortality be said of many of us to describe hell ''... Compelling food for thought and teacher of desiringGod.org and chancellor of Bethlehem Baptist Church, Minneapolis Minnesota! Can affect the presentation of the awfulness of the Gospel annihilationism desiring god it relates to the desires and of. Ever miss it but it truly experienced by those in heaven, from which he the. At one time it was there that human sacrifices were made to the lost, the nothingness that have!, life, and Imagination in the Greek -- a rather extensive.. Forever the horrible freedom they have demanded, and some of his are..., those who are not saved is literal and final death and destruction of is... Afraid that is what he does that someone has followed a false God with motives...