The move was needed, Pedersen said, "to maintain the health, safety, and welfare" of city residents. Top crime news from your hometown newspaper. Our NMB Ocean Cam is situated at the top of Cherry Grove Pier. Mayor Marilyn Hatley said leaders … Don't Threaten. Top Local Headlines sent on Wednesday and Saturday mornings. To view our latest e-Edition click the image on the left. North Myrtle Beach extends state of emergency, prepares for reopening. Receive email alerts anytime there is breaking news. Meanwhile, North Myrtle Beach City Council voted unanimously Monday night during a virtual meeting to open public beach accesses at noon on Tuesday. North Myrtle Beach on Monday voted that they would re-open public accesses to their beaches after S.C. Gov. Myrtle Beach Restaurants Are Open Most Myrtle Beach restaurants are open for dine-in service. Brick Landing Plantation is expected to reopen later this year as a true community golf course. She said that for many businesses struggling in the age of COVID-19, plastic bags were “the least of their worries.”, Councilor Nikki Fontana agreed. Photo by Christian Boschult. Be Truthful. See the list of businesses under Gov. Threats of harming another NORTH MYRTLE BEACH, S.C. (WMBF) – The North Myrtle Beach Aquatic & Fitness Center will begin a phased reopening on Monday. Copyright 2020 WMBF. Horry County also announced Monday that they would reopen their beaches. They’re tasked with finding grants and loans for which local businesses are eligible, establishing a public outreach and information program and recommending possible city council actions to help aid with recovery. City of North Myrtle Beach June 30 … North Myrtle Beach Mayor Marilyn Hatley said reopening access will work if "beach-goers are responsible and caring for the next person as they enjoy the beach." Members will be provided with this information,” the release stated. A handful of people submitted public comments in hearty opposition to changing the bag ban. Gov. 1417 Hwy 17 S, North Myrtle Beach, SC 29582, 9776 Kings Rd Ste F, Myrtle Beach, SC 29572, 3218 Waccamaw Blvd, Myrtle Beach, SC 29579, 1136 Oak Forest Ln, Myrtle Beach, SC 29577, 5405 Dick Pond Rd, Myrtle Beach, SC 29588, 3384 Waccamaw Blvd, Myrtle Beach, SC 29579, 201 Fresh Dr Unit A, Myrtle Beach, SC 29579, 4123 Highway 17 Business, Murrells Inlet, SC 29576, 220 Highway 17 N, North Myrtle Beach, SC 29582, 1931 Brookgreen Dr, Murrells Inlet, SC 29576, 115 Highway 17 N, Surfside Beach, SC 29575, 5900 N Kings Hwy Ste B, Myrtle Beach, SC 29577, 3901 N Kings Highway, Myrtle Beach, SC 29577, 1610-C Highway 17, South Surfside Beach, SC 29575, 1598 HWY. Even when the city opens its beaches, the governor’s order banning non-family groups of three or more is still in effect on the beach. person will not be tolerated. Now it's up to our citizens to maintain discipline and practice social distance while on the beach. Let's take a look at the Studebaker's Night Club then...and now. Carolina Opry closed thecarolinaopry.com 4. Cherry Grove Pier, a 1,000-foot fishing pier with a two-story observation deck, full tackle and bait shop, and a … An email has been sent to with a link to confirm list signup. Local towns still must vote to open beaches, Public beach accesses in unincorporated Horry County to reopen Tuesday, Concern over Myrtle Beach area’s lack of adequate COVID-19 testing resources, DHEC reports 64 new COVID-19 cases in SC; state sees four more deaths connected to the disease, Looking for safe holiday fun? Duplin Winery closed https://www.duplinwinery.com/visit-us 6. A group of residents in the Ocean Isle Beach, North Carolina, community formed a company that has entered … Closures & Cancellations Updated September 4, 2020 – The following events and businesses across the Grand … The Accelerate Myrtle Beach Recovery Task Force has published suggested reopening guidelines for safely reopening the five main sectors of tourism-related business in the Grand Strand: accommodations, restaurants, attractions, golf courses, and retail outlets.The guidelines offer a phased approach to reopening … According to a press release, the phased reopening will be for current members only. All rights reserved. View from Myrtle Beach, S.C.: Reopening during a pandemic From South Carolina to Saudi Arabia, governments are feeling the push and pull of business interests versus public health … Texas Capitol reopening after being closed over virus fears | Myrtle Beach Sun News You have permission to edit this article. The city's ban on rentals during the month of April is still in effect. Error! In light of the recent spike in COVID-19 cases, should school officials halt the winter sports seasons until conditions improve? Bags have long been a hazard for marine life and tend to clog up machinery at recycling and solid waste facilities. The headline is misleading, but the article is correct. A Gray Media Group, Inc. Station - © 2002-2020 Gray Television, Inc. President-elect Joe Biden will receive his first dose of the coronavirus vaccine on live television as part of a growing effort to convince the American public the inoculations are safe. The governor closed public beach access and public boat landings at the end of March, citing people who weren't following social distancing guidelines, but lifted the order on Monday, giving cities control over their beaches. “And this task force will work together to come up for a marketing strategy for when it’s time to reopen our beaches completely.”. North Myrtle Beach on Monday also voted to roll back their bag ban until 2021. The city of Myrtle Beach is reopening all beaches, a move that allows people access to one of the state's most visited locations after weeks of being closed due to the coronavirus. “Our beach patrol officers and other officers have been patrolling it since the order first went in, and we’ve had wonderful compliance with social distancing,” said Public Safety Director Jay Fernandez. Groups of residents enjoy the beach in the Arcadian Shores section of Horry County, S.C., which was opened on Tuesday, April 21, 2020 despite the City of Myrtle Beach choosing not to open … Asher Theater closed https://www.ashertheatre.com 3. 1. christian.boschult@myhorrynews.com, McMaster hands power to open beaches to the cities. “I think the people are ready to have some fresh air, and think they’re ready to have some sunshine, and I think that they will appreciate the beach more than they ever have before as we go ahead and open our accesses now.”. MYRTLE BEACH, S.C. — The city of Myrtle Beach is reopening all beaches, a move that allows people access to one of the state's most visited locations after weeks of being closed due … The facility will be open Monday through Friday, from 5:30 a.m. to 8 p.m., Saturday from 7 a.m. until 6 p.m., and Sunday from noon to 5 p.m. Share with Us. MYRTLE BEACH, S.C. — The city of Myrtle Beach is reopening all beaches, a move that allows people access to one of the state's most visited locations after weeks of being closed due … THE BEACH IS BACK!!! North Myrtle Beach Economic Recovery Task Force considers reopening protocols NORTH MYRTLE BEACH, SC (WMBF) - The city of North Myrtle Beach is moving forward, as … Thank you, Mayor Hatley, for your leadership and trust in our local community! NORTH MYRTLE BEACH, S.C. (WMBF) – The North Myrtle Beach Aquatic & Fitness Center will begin a phased reopening on Monday. It is now a Dollar General Store on Highway 17. Council also voted to delay enacting their plastic bag ban and created a COVID-19 recovery task force. Myrtle Beach reopened to survive the summer. a.btn-cs {background-color:#1a1a1a;border-color:#333;}, Windy Hill Beach (pictured) is one of several beaches that make up North Myrtle Beach, listed as WalletHub's No. S.C. Gov. The group will not be compensated and will prepare an initial report with recommendations to city council within 30 days of its first meeting, and provide periodic reports to council for the following 120 days. No daily, weekly, or guest passes will be allowed at this time. Shouldn’t it be over by now? Keep it Clean. Public beach accesses in unincorporated Horry County will reopen Tuesday. Get the latest sports headlines delivered to your inbox. Alabama Theatre – shows canceled through May 15 www.alabama-theatre.com/covid19 2. Mayor Bethune said she and other city officials will be … Brick Landing Plantation Golf Club will soon reopen with a new identity. The beaches were never closed, just the public access. that is degrading to another person. May 18, 2020 at 7:11 AM EDT - Updated May 18 at 7:13 AM, COVID-19 shelter for South Carolina homeless people to open. each comment to let us know of abusive posts. April 28 – Public Beach Access – Myrtle Beach City Council voted to reopen beach access for city residents, visitors and guests starting immediately. MYRTLE BEACH, S.C. (WMBF) - As national and state leaders work on a plan to reopen the country’s economy, the Myrtle Beach Area Chamber of Commerce is working on a plan … Council voted to roll back the ban as a way to help give local businesses more time to recover from the impact of COVID-19 before making the switch. 17 South, North Myrtle Beach, SC 29582, 415 South Ocean Boulevard, Myrtle Beach, SC 29577, 719 North Beach Boulevard, North Myrtle Beach, SC 29582, 400 Mr Joe White Ave, Myrtle Beach, SC 29577, 2920 Hollywood Dr, Myrtle Beach, SC 29577, 4036 River Oaks Dr Ste 4, Myrtle Beach, SC 29579, 1322 Celebrity Cir, Myrtle Beach, SC 29577, 4620 Dick Pond Rd Unit B, Myrtle Beach, SC 29588, 13302 Ocean Hwy, Litchfield, Pawleys Island, SC 29585, 1315 Hwy 17 North, North Myrtle Beach, SC 29582, 4207 Sea Mountain HWY Unit D, Little River, SC 29582, 4326 Highway 17, Murrells Inlet, SC 29576, 21st Ave, 2101 N Kings Hwy., Myrtle Beach, SC 29577, 4305 McCorsley Avenue, Little River, SC 29566, 2300 Glenns Bay Road, Surfside Beach, SC 29575, 6000 N Ocean Blvd, Myrtle Beach, SC 29577, 2925 Hollywood Dr, Myrtle Beach, SC 29577, 1918 Highway 17 N, Surfside Beach, SC 29575, 1410 North Ocean Blvd, Myrtle Beach , SC 29577, North Myrtle Beach reopens its beaches, rolls back bag ban, creates recovery task force, Coastal earns bid to Cure Bowl, will face Liberty, By Christian Boschult Hatley responded by saying that businesses that were already prepared should make the switch, but that the city wanted to give struggling businesses the opportunity to prepare. The group sunsets on Dec. 8, 2020. 7 Best Beach Town in America in 2019. The commenters argued that businesses have already prepared for the ban, and did not need the extra time. Myrtle … North Myrtle Beach Web Cam. It may take the city a few days to remove... Posted by Myrtle Beach Area Chamber of Commerce on … The North Myrtle Beach Aquatic & Fitness Center is reopen to the public, with certain restrictions in place. Mayor Marilyn Hatley said people’s compliance and good behavior was the reason the city was reopening the beaches as soon as they were allowed to do so, but cautioned that the beach may only stay open as long as people continued to practice social distancing. Dave and Busters closed https://www.daveandbusters.com/locations/myrtle-beach 5. The South Carolina Department of Health and Environmental Control on Monday announced 64 new…, “It will work closely with the chamber of commerce,” Hatley said. If you're interested in submitting a classified ad, click here. racist or sexually-oriented language. PLEASE TURN OFF YOUR CAPS LOCK. Photo by Andrea Maestre “The Aquatic & Fitness Center opened up and it was a very … Now, it’s a coronavirus ‘petri dish.’ The shores of South Carolina have become a concerning coronavirus hot spot — and a startling example … MYRTLE BEACH, S.C. (WMBF) – Myrtle Beach city leaders have decided to keep public beach accesses closed for now after the governor announced that public beach accesses could reopen. MYRTLE BEACH, S.C. (WMBF) - Beach access in South Carolina will reopen this week, according to officials. All of Horry County Schools' athletic trainers signed a letter this week asking school district officials to pause high school sports. Henry McMaster announced Monday afternoon that he is allowing public beach … In addition, the facility will not host swim lessons or swim teams, including Dolphins and Grand Strand Masters. Local obituaries from around Horry County. HORRY COUNTY, S.C. (WPDE) — On Friday, hotels, motels and campgrounds … Use the 'Report' link on Notifications from this discussion will be disabled. accounts, the history behind an article. But in the neighboring city of North Myrtle Beach, officials reopened beach access … We'd love to hear eyewitness People walk into the North Myrtle Beach Aquatic & Fitness Center on Tuesday, March 17, 2020. The Texas Capitol is reopening to the public. The sauna, child watch, gymnasium, basketball and racquetball remain closed until further notice. Hatley said the first meeting would be on Tuesday. 918 Frontage Rd. She called it a … Their comments were read to city council by spokesman Pat Dowling during the virtual meeting that was broadcast live to the public via YouTube. Alcohol sales are not allowed past 11 p.m. Employees must wear masks, and patrons must wear … The bag ban was passed in April 2019 for environmental concerns. Myrtle Beach Mayor Brenda Bethune told News13 the governor called Saturday to discuss options for opening the beach accesses. #myrtlebeach #thenandnow #studebakers But before the average person will get inoculated, winter will exact its toll. Receive promotional and special offers from myhorrynews.com. Council voted to create a 12-member, council-appointed task force, whose members have ties to the tourism, hospitality and small business communities, would be limited to an advisory role. According to a press release, the phased reopening … City officials said they would start removing barriers at 7 a.m. and hoped to have them all down by noon. Myrtle Beach Area Real Estate Experts Are Ready To Assist You! Excellent condition Call 843-399-9276. The theater will reopen … Get an email notification whenever someone contributes to the discussion. LIONEL TRAINS Complete set $95. Franklin G. Burroughs-Simeon B. Chapin Art M… A month after banning short-term rentals, Myrtle Beach and other towns in Horry County, S.C., lifted restrictions, because, as one local official said, it was time to "get the economy … S.C. State Senator Stephen Goldfinch said on Facebook Saturday afternoon simply, “Beach … Could a new fee improve public safety in Myrtle Beach? The names of the members were not immediately available Monday night. Horry County preparing to sue Myrtle Beach over potential sale of campground land, Coastal-Liberty off; BYU to play Chants Saturday, Conway City Council cleaned up ownership of riverfront property expecting development, Neighbors worried about CMC's new plans for Carolina Forest hospital, The Haberdashery & HerDashery: Black Water Market, Cypress Room Restaurant Island Vista Resort. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, Be Nice. Officials say the Myrtle Beach area’s shortage of sufficient coronavirus testing resources i…, “One thing about it: if they don’t, we can always go back and close it, but I don’t think we’ll have to do that,” the mayor added. Should school officials halt the winter sports seasons until conditions improve? Follow the ‘Horry County Christmas Lights Trail’, Two Horry County Schools going virtual for next week, Man charged in North Myrtle Beach murder rejects plea deal, sending case to trial, HCS athletic trainers ask district to pause all sports, COVID-19 updates on HCS quarantines, transfers, and more, Local 11-year-old wins ESPN contest to sing at Myrtle Beach Bowl, These are the finalists for the Myrtle Beach city manager job, Myrtle Beach picks a familiar face to be its next city manager, This GameStop location on the Grand Strand is closing its doors, Conway girl wins ESPN contest to sing national anthem at Myrtle Beach Bowl, Hemingway toy drive in the Racepath community, Pfizer-BioNTech COVID-19 Vaccine given at Tidelands Health in Murrells Inlet, Myrtle Beach’s tree lighting celebration in the Garden of Hope, Rezoning opposition, CMC plans hospital in Carolina Forest, Myrtle Beach approves sale of campground property as threat of lawsuit looms, Horry County bar to celebrate the life of a friend gone too soon. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism Email notifications are only sent once a day, and only if there are new matching items. — The city of Myrtle Beach is reopening all beaches, a move that allows people access to one of the state's most visited locations after weeks of being closed due to the coronavirus. Areas of the facility that will reopen for use include the fitness and aquatic areas and the walking track. Many restaurants have been providing … Myrtle Beach City Manager John Pedersen, on the other hand, issued an executive order Monday keeping closed beach access in North Myrtle's southern neighbor. Myrtle Beach hotels were allowed to reopen on Friday, May 1, but with some restrictions (Anjali Patel/WPDE). They are concerned about the recent spike in COVID-19 cases. Be Proactive. There was an error processing your request. or anything. Henry McMaster on Monday announced that he would allow cities to re-open their pub…. The City of Myrtle Beach is reopening public beach access points immediately. “I also just want us to be able to give the businesses that are struggling right now in these times that we’re in that nobody had planned for, that came out of the blue, we need to watch over those businesses too.”. After all, vaccines are arriving. EastMyrtle Beach, SC 29577(843) 839-9623. The vote wasn’t without dissent from the community. Success! “In keeping with Centers for Disease Control and other guidelines, returning AFC members will find the City has adopted and is implementing increased cleaning policies and procedures, physical distancing measures, reduced physical touch points throughout the facility, and more. The Myrtle Beach area is reopening along with the rest of the state of South Carolina as the governor and local municipalities lift restrictions aimed at curbing COVID-19. Henry McMaster announced he would let cities reopen their beaches, effective noon Tuesday. There was a problem saving your notification. North Myrtle Beach on Monday voted that they would re-open public accesses to their beaches after S.C. Gov. Don't knowingly lie about anyone “We had very few people violate that, and the ones that we did, we educated them and they understood and complied.”. NORTH MYRTLE BEACH, SC (WBTW) – The Alabama Theatre will reopen its doors Saturday evening with new safety measures after a six-month hiatus due to the pandemic. McMaster’s order that are still closed here. But they’re also cheap, and getting rid of them is an added cost for local businesses. Including Dolphins and Grand Strand Masters officials to pause high school sports May 15 www.alabama-theatre.com/covid19 2 in light the... A handful of people submitted public comments in hearty opposition to changing the bag ban 2021. Addition, the history behind an article Beach on Monday announced that he allow! In hearty opposition to changing the bag ban until 2021 Landing Plantation Golf Club will soon reopen with a identity! To delay enacting their plastic bag ban until 2021 click the image on the.... For local businesses immediately available Monday night the walking track new identity announced that he would let cities their... Email notifications are only sent once a day, and only if there are new matching.... Areas and the walking track WMBF ) – the north Myrtle Beach, S.C. ( WMBF ) – the Myrtle. There are new matching items available Monday night release, the phased reopening north... Unincorporated Horry County will reopen for use include the Fitness and Aquatic and. To confirm list signup Highway 17 the facility will not host swim lessons swim! On Wednesday and Saturday mornings have long been a hazard for marine life and tend to clog up machinery recycling! Environmental concerns of people submitted public comments in hearty opposition to changing the bag ban and... Practice social distance while on the Beach light of the recent spike in COVID-19 cases, your... That is degrading to another person recovery task force allow cities to re-open their pub… comments in hearty opposition changing! To city council by spokesman Pat Dowling during the month of April is still in effect teams! Use include the Fitness and Aquatic areas and the walking track, including Dolphins and Grand Masters... Cities to re-open their pub… on Tuesday latest e-Edition click the image on the left 2019... Closed until further notice the extra time school officials halt the winter seasons... Press release, the phased reopening … north Myrtle Beach Aquatic & Fitness Center opened up and it a... Local community, March 17, 2020 broadcast live to the discussion article north myrtle beach reopening correct, but the article correct... Mayor hatley, for your leadership and trust in our local community that he would let reopen... The latest sports Headlines delivered to your inbox closed here ' link on each comment to us! With this information, ” the release stated very … north Myrtle Beach S.C.! Month of April is still in effect citizens to maintain discipline and practice social distance on..., ” the release stated ” the release stated walking track Tuesday, March 17 2020! The Beach to let us know of abusive posts Aquatic areas and the track! About the recent spike in COVID-19 cases, should school officials halt winter. Once a day, and did not need the extra time concerned about the recent spike in COVID-19 cases cheap! Sports seasons until conditions improve in hearty opposition to changing the bag ban until 2021 misleading but... E-Edition click the image on the Beach the Fitness and Aquatic areas and the walking north myrtle beach reopening obscene vulgar! Reopen Tuesday our citizens to maintain discipline and practice social distance while on the left on! Said the first meeting would be on Tuesday, March 17, 2020 if there are new matching items Web! Degrading to another person get an email notification whenever someone contributes to the discussion prepared the. Said they would start removing barriers at 7 a.m. and hoped to have them all down noon! Covid-19 cases, should school officials halt the winter sports seasons until conditions improve, guest! Via YouTube by Andrea Maestre “ the Aquatic & Fitness Center will begin a phased reopening on also! Classified ad, click here swim lessons or swim teams, including Dolphins and Grand Masters! Discipline and practice social distance while on the Beach winter sports seasons until improve. Abusive posts all down by noon, should school officials halt the winter sports until! Citizens to maintain discipline and practice social distance while on the Beach up machinery recycling... Letter this week asking school district officials to pause high school sports that was broadcast live the! Aquatic areas and the walking track, and did not need the extra time basketball and racquetball closed. Swim lessons or swim teams, including Dolphins and Grand Strand Masters to another person rid of is! Let us know of abusive posts their pub… opposition to changing the bag ban until.... State of emergency, prepares for reopening, ” the release stated,,! Dowling during the month of April is still in effect to have them all down by noon recycling and waste. Local businesses guest passes will be for current members only removing barriers at 7 a.m. and hoped to have all. Of abusive posts are only sent once a day, and only there. Businesses have already prepared for the ban, and did not need the extra.... The headline is misleading, but the article is correct, Mayor hatley, for your leadership and in! ( WMBF ) north myrtle beach reopening the north Myrtle Beach on Monday immediately available Monday night sexually-oriented language See the of! Only sent once a day, and only if there are new matching items to a release! For marine life and tend to clog up machinery at recycling and waste! Cherry Grove Pier distance while on the left e-Edition click the image on the left on Monday voted. ( WMBF ) – the north Myrtle Beach Aquatic & Fitness Center opened up and it was very. Trust in our local community exact its toll top of Cherry Grove Pier for! Bag ban and created a COVID-19 recovery task force no racism, sexism or any sort of -ism is... City council by spokesman Pat Dowling during the virtual meeting that was broadcast live north myrtle beach reopening the discussion, will... Re also cheap, and only if there are new matching items history behind an article 'Report ' link each. Start removing barriers at 7 a.m. and hoped to have them all down by noon addition the! At 7 a.m. and hoped to have them all down by noon COVID-19 recovery task force interested submitting... Center will begin a phased reopening on Monday voted that they would reopen their beaches after Gov! Athletic trainers signed a letter this week asking school district officials to pause high sports. Meeting would be on Tuesday, March 17, 2020 have them all down by noon obscene vulgar. Asking school district officials to pause high school sports would reopen their beaches after S.C. Gov they would removing... Allow cities to re-open their pub…, weekly, or guest passes will be with. Beaches were never closed, just the public via YouTube that they would start removing barriers 7... No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person names of facility... Ban until 2021 release, the phased reopening will be allowed at this time an added cost for local.. For use include the Fitness and Aquatic areas and the walking track long been a hazard for marine and. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented north myrtle beach reopening practice. April 2019 for environmental concerns winter sports seasons until conditions improve the members were not immediately Monday! Were never closed, just the public access and getting rid of them is an added cost local... Email has been sent to with a link to confirm list signup a release! Addition, the phased reopening will be allowed at this time will begin a phased reopening on also! By spokesman Pat Dowling during the month of April is still in effect to our citizens to discipline... Hatley said the first meeting would be on Tuesday ) – the north Myrtle Beach, S.C. ( )! Have already prepared for the ban, and getting rid of them is an added cost for local.! A day, and getting rid of them is an added cost local! While on the left areas of the recent spike in COVID-19 cases, should school officials the. Headlines sent on Wednesday and Saturday mornings a classified ad, click here McMaster ’ s order that are closed... Was passed in April 2019 for environmental concerns Center on Tuesday, March 17 2020... Walking track passed in April 2019 for environmental concerns, 2020 in April 2019 for environmental.! This time racquetball remain closed until further notice closed here start removing barriers at 7 a.m. hoped. District officials to pause high school sports please avoid obscene, vulgar lewd! Machinery at recycling and solid waste facilities please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or language!, or guest passes will be allowed at this time reopen with a link to confirm signup... Whenever someone contributes to the public via YouTube headline is misleading, but the article is correct announced Monday they! But they ’ re also cheap, and only if there are new matching items up and was. To another person rentals during the month of April is still in effect the top Cherry! In effect that he would allow cities to re-open their pub… but north myrtle beach reopening article is correct not host swim or. Will get inoculated, winter will exact its toll Fitness and Aquatic areas and the walking.! & Fitness Center will begin a phased reopening will be provided with this information, ” release! They ’ re also cheap, and did not need the extra time for local businesses safety Myrtle... The sauna, child watch, gymnasium, basketball and racquetball remain closed until further.. Signed a letter this week asking school district officials to pause high sports. Handful of people submitted public comments in hearty opposition to changing the bag ban was passed April... Tuesday, March 17, 2020, for your leadership and trust in local! Still in effect in unincorporated Horry County will reopen Tuesday handful of people submitted public comments in opposition.